2026-10-09 arXiv (export API and PDF downloads)
Found via Google queries "Sommerfeld puzzle" fine structure formula Dirac coincidence old quantum theory, Ishiwara 1915 Wilson quantum condition phase integral independent of Sommerfeld history, Robotti 1986 hydrogen fine structure Paschen Sommerfeld history article; then arXiv export API by id and by title.
- Suslov, "The 'Sommerfeld Puzzle' and Its Extensions", arXiv:2401.07485 (Jan 2024), saved files/arXiv-2401.07485.pdf [web]. Abstract: "The exact agreement between the Sommerfeld (1916) and Dirac (1928) results for the energy levels of the relativistic hydrogen atom (the so-called 'Sommerfeld puzzle') is analyzed and extended. Werner Heisenberg called this coincidence a 'miracle' but Erwin Schroedinger described it as a fortuitous computational accident." Bears on claim 2: the book's energy formula is the same formula that the Dirac equation gives; the physical picture behind it (precessing relativistic ellipses, no spin) is not. Priority 2/3.
- Barley, Ruffing and Suslov, "Old Quantum Mechanics by Bohr and Sommerfeld from a Modern Perspective", arXiv:2506.00408 (2025), saved files/arXiv-2506.00408.pdf [web]. Re-derives the quantisation rules and energy levels by semiclassical methods, evaluates the Sommerfeld-type integrals by elementary means and connects them to the Schrödinger and Dirac equations; Google snippet: "Measurements of fine-structure splitting by Paschen were interpreted as experimental tests of the special theory of relativity." Bears on claims 1 and 2; useful for the primer's worked example (elementary evaluation of the radial phase integral).
- Pelogia and Brasil, "Analysis of the Jun Ishiwara's 'The universal meaning of the quantum of action'", arXiv:1708.04676 (2017), saved files/arXiv-1708.04676-Ishiwara.pdf [web]. Ishiwara (Sendai), Proc. Tokyo Math.-Phys. Soc. 8 (1915) 106-116, proposed phase-space-integral quantisation "simultaneously with Arnold Sommerfeld, William Wilson and Niels Bohr". Priority 3 (closely related work): the claim-1 quantum condition was found independently by at least three people in 1915; the book credits Wilson and Ishiwara (deep read, Ch. IV people list). Duncan and Janssen, "Quantization Conditions, 1900-1927" (PhilSci-Archive, 2020) was seen in the results but not opened.
- Frauenfelder and Weber, "The fine structure of Weber's hydrogen atom - Bohr-Sommerfeld approach", arXiv:1902.09612 (2019; ZAMP per INIS snippet), saved files/arXiv-1902.09612-Weber-hydrogen-fine-structure.pdf [web]. Abstract: they determine, to second order in the fine-structure constant, the energy levels of Weber's Hamiltonian admitting a quantized torus; "Our formula coincides with the formula obtained by Wesley using the Schrödinger equation for Weber's Hamiltonian." Priority 3: Sommerfeld's method applied to Weber electrodynamics (a 19th-century velocity-dependent force law that mainstream physics regards as superseded) instead of special relativity. It bears on claim 6, which treats the fine structure as a test that singles out relativity: here a different velocity-dependent dynamics is put through the same quantisation. Whether its fine-structure numbers match Sommerfeld's was not checked (not read).