i-logic.com/relativity: archive of Silvertooth papers

  • URL: https://i-logic.com/relativity/ (a directory listing; operator not identified; files dated 10/02/2018).
  • Chrome: "Permission denied for reading page content on this domain" (extension site permission). That counts as a Chrome failure, so WebFetch was used as the fallback for the listing and two PDFs.
  • Silvertooth files: Silvertooth1.jpg, Silvertooth2.jpg, Silvertooth3.pdf (723 KB), Silvertooth4.pdf (938 KB), Silvertooth5.pdf (237 KB). Also WW1978-Oct-p44-45.pdf (probably L. Essen, Wireless World Oct 1978 p.44, cited in the 1989 article), Dingle-ScienceAtTheCrossroads.pdf and GPS.pdf.
  • Silvertooth4.pdf, from a Google snippet: R. G. Newburgh, "Relativistic phase invariance: comments on a recent effort to reinvoke the ether", Appl. Opt. 1977, U.S. Air Force RADC/Deputy for Electronic Technology, Hanscom AFB. Not read this run.
  • Saved (WebFetch cache, copied to research/files/):
  • Silvertooth3.pdf = Applied Optics 15(5), May 1976, pp. 1100-1102: Silvertooth, "Electromagnetic radiation, relativity, and anomalous red-shifts". File: files/Silvertooth-1976-AppliedOptics-15-1100-anomalous-redshifts.pdf
  • Silvertooth5.pdf = Applied Optics 22(9), 1983, p. 1274: Silvertooth & Jacobs, "Standing wave sensor". File: files/Silvertooth-Jacobs-1983-AppliedOptics-22-1274-standing-wave-sensor.pdf

1976 paper, key content [web: page images p.1101-1102 of the saved PDF]

  • Author address: 974 Flintridge Avenue, Pasadena. Received 23 May 1975. Sponsored (OSA Letter endorsement) by John Strong, University of Massachusetts.
  • Argument: accept the Lorentz transforms. The Sagnac phase along a segment L is δ = L·v/(cλ), independent of r. He argues the two postulates are then mutually inconsistent if δ is observable. Plotted against path curvature, relativity would need a discontinuity at zero curvature, "a physical impossibility". This is the same Sagnac step as the 1986 paper (assumption A3 in the deep read), 10 years earlier.
  • He quotes Simon Newcomb's 1881 letter to Michelson (National Archives RG78): motion "makes itself felt by a difference in the wavelength and velocities of propagation in different directions," which a round trip cancels. This is a historical precedent for Silvertooth's principle.
  • Earlier experiment with a NULL result: two free-running single-mode lasers in opposite directions; two 500 Å semitransparent photocathode detectors 50 cm apart; granite block on an overhead air bearing. For Δv/c = 1e-4 he expected 79 cycles on a 90-degree rotation. "No phase shift was observed." He read this as showing that the relative phase is invariant with v. He concluded the Sagnac shift comes from a change in frequency and velocity, with the wavelength change a result.
  • He proposes an E-W two-oscillator phase test. With L = 2 m and v_max = 3e6 cm/s at ν = 8.85e13 Hz, he predicts a 59-cycle peak-to-peak diurnal variation. "Execution of an experiment along these general lines is presently under way at the University of Arizona Optical Sciences Center" (ref: Third-Quarter FY75 Applied Optics Research Report, OSC, May 1975).
  • Origin of 1986 eq. (10): if v changes with time, δ̇ = L·v̇/(cλ), a frequency shift. This gives ν_o = (ν_s/γ)(1 ± v_r/c)(1 ± L·v̇_r/c²), where v̇_r is the radial acceleration of the source. Quasar case: in a rotating galaxy, a quasar at distance d from the centre along the line of sight has v̇_r = d·ω². So the bar in the 1986 retyping's "v̄" is most probably a dot (time derivative). The term L·v̇/c² is then dimensionless, which resolves the deep read's units question. That is an inference from the 1976 text and needs the Mathematician's check.
  • Hypotheses (1)-(6), including "(4) Absolute velocity can be measured" and "(5) ... absolute acceleration may be measured independent of ... a gravitational field".
  • Acknowledgements: Tube Department, General Electric Co., Syracuse (special detectors); Gordon Orme; John Strong.
  • Replies in Applied Optics 16(3), 1977: Øyvind Grøn, "On Silvertooth's discussion of special relativity" (p.543), and Silvertooth's "author's reply to comments" (p.543-544) [web: Optica search]. Not read.

1983 paper [web: saved PDF]

  • Silvertooth (Pasadena) and S. F. Jacobs (University of Arizona Optical Sciences Center). Received 13 January 1983. The detector is described as a photoelectric analogue of Wiener's 1890 photographic standing-wave experiment. The node/antinode ratio measured was about 20,000:1, giving an effective photosensitive thickness < λ/100. Photomultiplier made from image-orthicon parts at GE Syracuse. Thanks "Bob Shannon" (Robert Shannon, OSC director; identification is [memory, medium]).

Bearing

  • Claim 5: the derivation and meaning of eq. (10), and the quasar mechanism, are in the 1976 paper.
  • Claims 1-2: the same principle published in 1976 with a mainstream-journal reply (Grøn, Newburgh).
  • Claim 4: a NULL result in the earlier two-laser experiment (1975-76) is pertinent and stays in the record. It also documents the University of Arizona connection (Jacobs, OSC report FY75).