RankingsPrimerArbiterPhysicistMathematicianContrarianQESites logClaimsSourcesResearch notes

2026-10-04: arXiv (Wang, Zheng, Yao, Langley: fiber optic conveyor experiments)

Queries: Google Wang Zheng Yao Langley 2003 "uniformly moving fiber" Sagnac Physics Letters A; Google "Generalized Sagnac effect" Wang Zheng Yao Physical Review Letters 2004 fiber optic conveyor linear. Result: positive. Copies saved: - research/files/wang-2003-modified-sagnac-uniformly-moving-fiber-arXiv-physics-0609222.pdf (https://arxiv.org/abs/physics/0609222; journal: Phys. Lett. A 312 (2003) 7-10, doi:10.1016/S0375-9601(03)00575-9) - research/files/wang-2004-generalized-sagnac-effect-PRL93-143901-arXiv-physics-0609235.pdf (https://arxiv.org/pdf/physics/0609235; journal: Phys. Rev. Lett. 93 (2004) 143901)

Found [web]

  • Wang et al. 2003 (St. Cloud State University and St. John's University, Minnesota; fiber optic gyroscope (FOG) on loan from the Naval Research Laboratory): a "fiber optic conveyor" (FOC), a fibre loop running round two wheels like a belt, with long straight segments moving uniformly. Comparing loops with the same semicircular ends but different straight lengths, they found the phase shift grows linearly with the length of the uniformly moving segment. Abstract: "there is a travel-time difference Δt = 2vΔl/c² in a fiber segment of length Δl moving with the source and detector at a speed v, whether the segment is moving uniformly or circularly."
  • Their stated motivation: "to examine whether the travel-time difference only appears in rotational motion, or if it also appears in uniform motion." Discussion: "the length and speed of the moving fiber are the fundamental factors, rather than the enclosed area"; result independent of refractive index, which "implies that the same should occur in vacuum", testable with hollow-core fibre. They note Sagnac interpreted the effect without relativity.
  • Wang, Zheng, Yao 2004 (PRL): a loop of linearly and circularly moving segments; each segment contributes Δφ = 4π v·Δl/(cλ) (projection of the segment on the direction of motion), "independent of the type of motion and the refractive index"; includes rotation as a special case (via Stokes' theorem) and proposes a fibre-optic linear-motion sensor. Later citing work: Huang 2021 (Eur. Phys. J. D, sensor design); "One-way interferometer" (SCIRP); "Analysis of the Phase Difference in a Fiber-Optical Conveyor" (General Science Journal). Google shows about 150 citations for each paper.

Bearing on the claims

  • Claim 1 (Sagnac applies to uniform straight-line motion) is in Kelly's paper explicitly built on Wang et al. 2003. These are the primary experimental papers. Note for reviewers: in the FOC, the source and detector move with the fibre and the loop is closed (the belt has curved ends). Wang's segment-wise statement Δt = 2vΔl/c² is what Kelly generalises. Whether a uniformly translating closed loop as a whole gives any shift is a different question: the contributions from oppositely moving straight runs add, because they move in opposite directions. Leads, not verdicts.
  • Claim 2: Wang's formula Δt = 2vL/c² is the same form as Kelly's polygon derivation (D = ∮u dl).